Responses to Your Stonyfield Questions

Mastermind Weekend 1/16

Hey there!

I'm Tina

I’m the owner of Carrots ‘N’ Cake as well as a Certified Nutrition Coach and Functional Diagnostic Nutrition Practitioner (FDN-P). I use macros and functional nutrition to help women find balance within their diets while achieving their body composition goals.


An in-depth, 4-week reverse dieting course for women who feel like their metabolism has slowed down, think they might have hormonal imbalance and can’t lose weight no matter what they do.

A few of you guys asked some really great questions in the comment section of my Stonyfield Barnstorming Tour Recap post. I wasn’t 100% sure how to respond, so I asked my friends at Stonyfield to help me out. They sent me a detailed email with their answers, so I wanted to share them on CNC since other people might be interested to read them as well.


Do you think they “cleaned up” the place before the blogger/journalists arrived?

Anytime we entertain visitors, we all clean up a bit. (In fact, we’re pretty sure the farmers themselves took special care to look their best during our visit!) However, during our trip we passed multiple farms who sell their milk to Stonyfield that were not expecting our visit and anyone can check in on many of our farms day-to-day to see what is taking place at our farm cam site: and on Jonathan Gates’ Bovine Bugle Blog:

I always buy organic milk and dairy products but I read a while ago that dairy cows are impregnated all the time so that they can continue to produce milk. Also if they have a male calf than he is usually just sent to the slaughter house for veal as a male dairy calf is clearly useless. Did they touch base on any of this information while you were there? I am curious as to how it works at real dairy farms and not just conventional ones. I am vegetarian but havent made the switch to vegan simply because I love dairy, but after reading about that it made me sad.

We purchase our organic milk from Organic Valley/CROPP, a farmer-owned cooperative of over 1,300 dairy farmers. Humane animal treatment is a cornerstone of organic and CROPP farmers work to minimize cows’ stress in all areas – including breeding. Dairy farmers strive to have their cows calve (or have a calf) once a year. If a cow does not get pregnant, her milk production drops to such a level that it is not economically viable to keep her. The last 60 days of the pregnancy are a rest period for the cow in preparation for the birth of the calf. During that time she is not milked. The gestation period for a cow is the same as that for people–9 months. So if a cow gets pregnant on her first attempt at breeding she will milk on average for about 305 days out of the year with 60 days of rest.

And, all diary farmers would rather have a heifer calf than a bull calf so that they can grow their herd or sell it for a decent sum. No dairy farmer is pleased to have a cow birth a bull. As long as people buy veal, there will be bull calves sent to veal operations – organic and non-organic (although organic standards prohibit the inhumane practices of conventional veal production). Most bull calves are sold for slaughter as the farmers cannot afford to keep them as pets. More and more however, Organic Valley farmers are raising the males as steers for the organic meat market or selling them to other organic farmers that specialize in beef. As the market for organic beef grows, this will allow more farmers to keep the bull calves to raise for beef. We believe that family farmers in the U.S. and around the world hold the key to implementing sustainable agriculture is defines as that which is ecologically sound, economically viable, socially just, and humane.

For more information visit Organic Valley’s website here:

My only question I have for Stonyfield, and this is actually a question, not a criticism, but why did they choose Wal Mart as one of their vendors? While I understand that bringing organic produce to the masses is important, is there also the thought that not participating in stores that are a little lacking in business ethics would be another stance organic vendors can take?? Wal Mart is known for bullying small farmers into lower prices so that products can fit into the “low price” model. But the reason corporate farms are cheap is because they skimp on environmental issues to fit in with this model. Small farmers are unable to do so, hence higher prices”¦ that’s my only beef with Stonyfield. and I am open to the idea that I’m completely misinformed as well. There is so much information out there, it’s hard to know what’s real and not.

Distributing our products to WalMart is just one more way that we can bring the benefits of organic food to mainstream shoppers. If organic is going to provide future generations with a healthier, safer way of life, organic must become mainstream. More people shop at WalMart than voted in the last U.S. election – twice as many, in fact. Increasing the awareness and appreciation of organics and family farming with this large audience is critical to the future growth of organics and the health of the planet. We believe that this is central to our mission. We believe that all of agriculture must change to organic practices in order to (a) rid the world of unnecessary, persistent and toxic agricultural chemicals, (b) reduce the carbon footprint of modern agricultural practices so as to minimize food production’s contribution to climate change and (c) provide a fair and sustainable livelihood for family farmers around the world. In order to fulfill this objective, we believe that we need to alter the food choices anywhere that food is bought and sold. Since WalMart is one of the world’s largest grocers, we do not feel that we, or future generations, can afford the luxury of ignoring the profound influence that they can have on agriculture and the food industry.

(Know too, that we respect that everyone chooses to shop in different locations and we work hard to offer our products in as many stores as possible – from WalMart to Whole Foods to grocery stores and small independent shops.)



  1. That’s awesome that they responded directly to the questions you received, even if I don’t regularly buy Stonyfield products (I buy Wegmans-brand milk, and I have tried Stonyfield Greek yogurt, but prefer the taste of other brands. I do think they have a good regular yogurt in chocolate/coffee/mocha flavors though!)

  2. oh wow I didn’t know that about the baby cows! There is actually a LOT I don’t know about dairy farming actually — I don’t drink milk but I certainly do eat cheese and want to learn more now! =) thanks so much for answering these questions <3 I'm off to research my butt off!

  3. These are great answers! I love the Stonyfield brand anyway, but even more so now. I just wish they had wider-spread availability in Canada!

  4. I appreciate their response and it does make sense. I also appreciate the comment that came from someone (I cannot remember her name) where she said that sometimes people don’t have access to a Whole Foods or specialty grocery store and wal mart may be the only option. So I have been proven wrong!!! There are always multiple sides to an opinion and I always like hearing them because I want to me open minded, not judgmental. i appreciate you taking the time to do this.

  5. This is great, thanks for sharing their answers and for getting in touch with them. Certain products will always be in demand; no matter how controversial they are. But I think that’s good – everyone’s different and everyone likes different things. It’s great that Stonyfield supports so many consumers.

  6. I love the honesty behind the answers, especially question 1. Also with regards to the Wal Mart question, I totally agree that despite the store’s ethics, it’s an efficient way to provide more shoppers with organic products!

  7. I’m a farm reporter, and I just interviewed a dairy farmer who is using a technology that almost guarantees that a cow will give birth to a female calf (or heifer). I would describe it more in detail, but your spam filter may block my post if I did 🙂 But in essence, it means that the cows aren’t producing any bull calves that just go to slaughter.

    Farmers are using new technology to make sure that they are more efficient while still caring for the animals and the environment. One of my concerns about the organic trend is that we may be taking away this technology from farmers. And there are a lot of hungry people in the world who depend on farmers to feed us. We need both organic and conventional farms now more than ever. Thanks for the discussion.

  8. Tina,

    Thanks so much for sharing re the stonyfield trip!

    I actually wanted to comment on your GI issues but wasn’t sure you would notice my comment in the previous post. I highly recommend getting tested for food allergies. You can get a panel done full panel done for $100 to $200. I know that that isn’t chump change by any stretch but you might spend more with traditional doctors trying to figure out what is going on and have those tests go nowhere.

    My mom and I both struggled with GI issues at different times in our lives and my symptoms were exactly like yours. All of our problems were caused or exacerbated by food sensitivities. It may seem odd that a food you have loved and eaten without reaction for so long may now cause trouble but the body can build up immunities to seemingly healthy products.

    The obvious possible culprits are soy, wheat, dairy, eggs, nuts but truly it could be anything.

    I wish all the best and hope you feel better soon just wanted to offer my experience!

  9. Hi Tina,

    This is not meant to sound mean or overly critical, but I feel that your blog has really changed a lot in the last year, and not for the better :(. I LOVE your blog, but lately it feels like it concerns 3 things: advertising/promotional pieces, dogs, and random events that you get invited to participate in. I miss the old Carrots N Cake! I would just love to see more about you and your daily life, instead of things about random companies that I am not so interested in.

    Just my opinion, take it or leave it. Again, not meant to be mean, just honest.


    1. @Lena: I’m actually not sure what “old” CNC you are talking about. I don’t think my blog has changed all that much. I actually think my blog has gotten better lately! I’m sorry you don’t like it.

  10. Just read your Twitter comment about “haters.” Hope that didn’t refer to my earlier comment. I read your blog everyday, so I’m obviously a fan.

  11. Thanks for sharing these questions and answers! I found them to be extremely informative and brought up a lot of good discussion.

    I, for one, love when you can give us greater insight into companies like Stonyfield’s. =) Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Join the community!

Get recipes, workouts. and discounts straight to your inbox for FREE!
© 2022 Carrots ‘N’ Cake. All Rights Reserved | An Elite CafeMedia Food Publisher | Funnel Build & Design by: Maria Filipina Co.